Robert Jensen – It's Debatable

For our last meeting of 2024 on 30 December we discussed the dropped chapter from Robert Jensen’s It’s Debatable: Talking Authentically about Tricky Topics.


Chapter 5, titled ‘Defining Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology’, is freely available on Jensen’s website. The chapter was dropped from the book following “a constructive conversation” between Jensen and the publisher Interlink Publishing.


On his website (linked above) Jensen explains part of the reason for the chapter being dropped and also links to Interlink’s intended statement on not including the chapter in the book.


Unfortunately that page on Interlink’s website (https://www.interlinkbooks.com/itsdebatable_note/) seems to have never materialised.


At the start of the group Björn noted how some of the content of the chapter will probably have been very familiar to most of us, but that some of it would have been quite new to others, in particular the ecological / eco-feminist parts. David agreed and thought first half was really well presented. He considered it a very valuable and thorough summary of ‘gender critical’ arguments. For David, the ecological arguments opposing transgender ideology were new, such as the argument that we cannot use science and engineering to change what we are given by nature.


Robbie agreed with David’s that Jensen provided a very good summary and that perhaps for those of us familiar with the subject there was perhaps not much novel content. To Robbie the eco-angle was also somewhat new and he wondered whether there would have been scope to link it to transhumanism, which Robbie is quite familiar with. Transhumanism as Robbie explained it is a “project that disassociates the meat puppet of the human body from the gendered soul”. In this context he mentioned Martine Rothblatt, a well-known proponent of transhumanism and the work of Jennifer Bilek and her blog The 11th Hour. Bilek has been researching the gender industry and the connections between technology, transsexualism, and transhumanism for over a decade and Robbie would very much have liked for Jensen to have extended this chapter to include transhumanism and some of Bilek’s contributions in that sphere. In particular with regards to the way in which capitalism plays a part in it all (i.e. following where the money comes from and goes to).


Prior to reading It’s Debatable, John had also not made the connection between transgenderism and transhumanism and recognised that in theory there are no limits to what humans could do. We could try and find a technological solution to pretty much anything leading to extreme forms of biohacking and the total changing of our natural selves. In a way a transhumanist approach means that biological facts – i.e. the fact that you are a man can be reframed into a ‘technical’ problem that can be solved with a ‘technical’ solutions, such as invasive body-modification through the use of invasive surgical procedures and chemicals.


Björn noted how on a deeper level much of what Jensen mentioned seemed deeply interlinked with the patriarchal aim of having power / overpowering, which is expressed in many different ways, from violence towards others (sexual violence and exploitation, war, slavery etc.) to violence against nature (exploitation of animals, deforestation, environmental pollution etc.). Björn added how the vast majority of billionaires are men (approx. 86% according to a recent Forbes piece) with men like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Larry Ellison, Mark Zuckerberg etc. driving technological advances and from a desire to ‘overcome’ nature and its limitations as well as making money.


“Sex is in some sense assigned by someone, such as the woman giving birth, or a midwife assisting with a home birth, or a doctor in a hospital. But “assigned” implies an arbitrary decision. If I am assigned a seat at a dinner party, for example, it’s understood to be the choice of the host. But sex is observed at birth, not assigned.”
Robert Jensen – Defining Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology (p. 3)


John took the discussion back to transgenderism and noted how skilfully Jensen pointed out the inconsistencies in much of the activist language as well as the fact that many people seem to willingly accept that there is no proof under the banner “you just have to believe”. Alongside that stands another point of view, which prescribes that men who say that they are women have the right not to have any questions asked of them. The problem with these fixed ideas is that they shut down any discussion and that those who pursue debate regardless are judged to be bigoted. All of this goes completely against any sort of scientific enquiry of course.


David remarked that the fact that the chapter was dropped from the book, really makes the point for Robert Jensen and people’s lacking willingness to exchange ideas on the subject. In relation to this Björn pointed out that there is a passage in the published book, available online here, that explains why the chapter Definging Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology was not included in the book. In a way it is a real win to have this note in the book for future generations to see and consider. Particularly as the note on the publisher’s website does not appear to ever have gone live, which is curious to say the least. It’s almost as if Interlink Publishing / Olive Branch Press had second thoughts about their decision to drop the chapter. Perhaps they decided not to publish the note on their website because the debate had changes so much in the time between their decision and publication of the book. Or perhaps they were worried that people would remember the book more for the content that was omitted, rather than the content that made it into the book. John pointed out that there isn’t such a thing as bad publicity and felt uncertain that a ‘fear of bad press’ was a likely reason for not publishing a statement.


The discussion then went back to the start of the book and Jensen’s reference of of critical race theory. Robbie felt the link to critical race theory, which holds that many aspects of western society contain inherent racial bias was very useful. In particilar with regards to the very different ways in which left-leaning people have responded to this theory and to gender ideology. Robbie expressed incredulity about those ‘on the left’ who accept men who claim to be a different sex (i.e. women), reject the idea that white people can claim to be another ethnicity (i.e. black), as in the example of Rachel Dolezal.


Our discussion then turned to our real-life interactions with people who see themselves as being very pro ‘trans rights’. William felt that reading Jensen’s chapter has given him a lot of information and context that he did not have before and as a result he felt better prepared to have discussions with others about the subject matter. William very much felt that what Jensen provided would support him in bringing his point of view across much more clearly, equipping him with well considered points.


At this point John a further point, namely that having open conversations with friends may be ‘just’ uncomfortable or difficult, having these at work may indeed be career-limiting (as experienced by many women and some men). John felt that it was troubling to recognise how many of us feel unable to state our opinions, particularly as it prevents us from being the change we want to see.


In this respect we spoke about the various SEEN Networks that have been popping up in the UK since 2022. According to their own website, SEEN is “a staff network committed to promoting and supporting sex equality and equity between women and men in our workplaces, and helping all staff to thrive at work and fulfil their potential”. Since the start of the first SEEN in 2022, there are now at least 13 networks across sectors.


We continued by discussing the benefit of SEEN Networks, in that it gives members an opportunity to come together, organise events and try and change the culture at work by opening up discussions from within. Whilst in practice SEEN Networks are often more tolerated than actively promoted by organisations, it is nonetheless important that they exist as their mere existence, challenges the established culture.


Going back to John’s question about real-life conversations regarding different points of view, Robbie pointed out that he has often found himself trying to open up conversations and brokering discussions and failing due to people being unwilling to engage in debate. For him, this resulted in being forced out of the Green Party along with many other members of the party. You can find out more about them on the website Greens In Exile. Robbie mentioned that there is now a badge for the exiles reading ‘Greens in Exile’. Robbie feels that wearing it helps open up discussions about what is happening in the Green Party in particular, but in society in general as well.


The discussion then turned to the final passage of the book. Robbie felt quite confused with the last line of the book in which Jensen said that “A radical feminist analysis, rooted in an ecological worldview, offers a path to a deeper analysis and potentially more effective responses.“. Robbie felt that the book ended rather abruptly at this point and he was left with wondering about the available choices would be if they weren’t either a “liberal embrace or a conservative rejection”. Robbie’s confusion stemmed from a realisation that meeting people in different arenas requires a ‘need’ to adapt your language and as such he was unsure which responses radical feminism would be able to provide in those contexts. Robbie’s confusion stemmed from a rather literal reading of the passage. Björn, who had taken the sentence in a more philosophical way, felt that Jensen was trying to say that issues are complex and our responses to them should be informed by deep thinking and critical analysis from a radical feminist perspective. Only by engaging in that way, can we ensure that the responses we come up with are better than the blanket responses of ‘affirmation’ on one side versus ‘rejection’ on the other.


To round the discussion off, Chris noted how Jensen had vehemently rejected the term ‘TERF’ and how important this was, in a sense of not describing ourselves or others using derogatory and incorrect terms. Neither radical feminists nor MACS exclude people who identify as trans. We are simply concerned about protecting vulnerable women, children, same-sex attracted people and bisexual people and want to stop anyone from doing anything nasty.


Chris’ point garnered some support, whilst others felt it was possible to reclaim derogatory terms like ‘TERF’. In the end we had to agree to disagree, whether such a reclaiming is indeed possible. We ended the discussion by reflecting on our takes on various ‘labels’ currently doing the rounds that reflect ‘gender critical’ views. These included ‘gender atheist’, ‘gender realist’ or ‘sex realist’ (a term that someone had come across on Reality’s Last Stand).

For our last meeting of 2024 on 30 December we discussed the dropped chapter from Robert Jensen’s It’s Debatable: Talking Authentically about Tricky Topics.


Chapter 5, titled ‘Defining Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology’, is freely available on Jensen’s website. The chapter was dropped from the book following “a constructive conversation” between Jensen and the publisher Interlink Publishing.


On his website (linked above) Jensen explains part of the reason for the chapter being dropped and also links to Interlink’s statement on publishing the book.


Unfortunately that page on Interlink’s website (https://www.interlinkbooks.com/itsdebatable_note/) has been deleted permanently and appears unretrievable even with a service like the Wayback Machine.


At the start of the group Björn noted how some of the content of the chapter will probably have been very familiar to most of us, but that some of it would have been quite new to others, in particular the ecological / eco-feminist parts. David agreed and thought first half was really well presented. He considered it a very valuable and thorough summary of ‘gender critical’ arguments. For David, the ecological arguments opposing transgender ideology were new, such as the argument that we cannot use science and engineering to change what we are given by nature.


Robbie agreed with David’s that Jensen provided a very good summary and that perhaps for those of us familiar with the subject there was perhaps not much novel content. To Robbie the eco-angle was also somewhat new and he wondered whether there would have been scope to link it to transhumanism, which Robbie is quite familiar with. Transhumanism as Robbie explained it is a “project that disassociates the meat puppet of the human body from the gendered soul”. In this context he mentioned Martine Rothblatt, a well-known proponent of transhumanism and the work of Jennifer Bilek and her blog The 11th Hour. Bilek has been researching the gender industry and the connections between technology, transsexualism, and transhumanism for over a decade and Robbie would very much have liked for Jensen to have extended this chapter to include transhumanism and some of Bilek’s contributions in that sphere. In particular with regards to the way in which capitalism plays a part in it all (i.e. following where the money comes from and goes to).


Prior to reading It’s Debatable, John had also not made the connection between transgenderism and transhumanism and recognised that in theory there are no limits to what humans could do. We could try and find a technological solution to pretty much anything leading to extreme forms of biohacking and the total changing of our natural selves. In a way a transhumanist approach means that biological facts – i.e. the fact that you are a man can be reframed into a ‘technical’ problem that can be solved with a ‘technical’ solutions, such as invasive body-modification through the use of invasive surgical procedures and chemicals.


Björn noted how on a deeper level much of what Jensen mentioned seemed deeply interlinked with the patriarchal aim of having power / overpowering, which is expressed in many different ways, from violence towards others (sexual violence and exploitation, war, slavery etc.) to violence against nature (exploitation of animals, deforestation, environmental pollution etc.). Björn added how the vast majority of billionaires are men (approx. 86% according to a recent Forbes piece) with men like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Larry Ellison, Mark Zuckerberg etc. driving technological advances and from a desire to ‘overcome’ nature and its limitations as well as making money.


“Sex is in some sense assigned by someone, such as the woman giving birth, or a midwife assisting with a home birth, or a doctor in a hospital. But “assigned” implies an arbitrary decision. If I am assigned a seat at a dinner party, for example, it’s understood to be the choice of the host. But sex is observed at birth, not assigned.”
Robert Jensen – Defining Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology (p. 3)


John took the discussion back to transgenderism and noted how skilfully Jensen pointed out the inconsistencies in much of the activist language as well as the fact that many people seem to willingly accept that there is no proof under the banner “you just have to believe”. Alongside that stands another point of view, which prescribes that men who say that they are women have the right not to have any questions asked of them. The problem with these fixed ideas is that they shut down any discussion and that those who pursue debate regardless are judged to be bigoted. All of this goes completely against any sort of scientific enquiry of course.


David remarked that the fact that the chapter was dropped from the book, really makes the point for Robert Jensen and people’s lacking willingness to exchange ideas on the subject. In relation to this Björn pointed out that there is a passage in the published book, available online here, that explains why the chapter Definging Sex/Gender: Beyond Trans Ideology was not included in the book. In a way it is a real win to have this note in the book for future generations to see and consider. Particularly as the note on the publisher’s website has now gone, which is curious to say the least. It’s almost as if Interlink Publishing / Olive Branch Press had second thoughts about their decision to drop the chapter. Perhaps they removed the note on their website because debate had moved on a lot in the last year or so since the decision was made. Or perhaps they were worried that people would remember the book more for the content that was omitted from the book, rather than the content that made it into the book. John pointed out that there isn’t such a thing as bad publicity and felt uncertain that a ‘fear of backlash’ was a likely reason for the page having been taken down.


The discussion then went back to the start of the book and Jensen’s reference of of critical race theory. Robbie felt the link to critical race theory, which holds that many aspects of western society contain inherent racial bias was very useful. In particilar with regards to the very different ways in which left-leaning people have responded to this theory and to gender ideology. Robbie expressed incredulity about those ‘on the left’ who accept men who claim to be a different sex (i.e. women), reject the idea that white people can claim to be another ethnicity (i.e. black), as in the example of Rachel Dolezal.


Our discussion then turned to our real-life interactions with people who see themselves as being very pro ‘trans rights’. William felt that reading Jensen’s chapter has given him a lot of information and context that he did not have before and as a result he felt better prepared to have discussions with others about the subject matter. William very much felt that what Jensen provided would support him in bringing his point of view across much more clearly, equipping him with well considered points.


At this point John a further point, namely that having open conversations with friends may be ‘just’ uncomfortable or difficult, having these at work may indeed be career-limiting (as experienced by many women and some men). John felt that it was troubling to recognise how many of us feel unable to state our opinions, particularly as it prevents us from being the change we want to see.


In this respect we spoke about the various SEEN Networks that have been popping up in the UK since 2022. According to their own website, SEEN is “a staff network committed to promoting and supporting sex equality and equity between women and men in our workplaces, and helping all staff to thrive at work and fulfil their potential”. Since the start of the first SEEN in 2022, there are now at least 13 networks across sectors.


We continued by discussing the benefit of SEEN Networks, in that it gives members an opportunity to come together, organise events and try and change the culture at work by opening up discussions from within. Whilst in practice SEEN Networks are often more tolerated than actively promoted by organisations, it is nonetheless important that they exist as their mere existence, challenges the established culture.


Going back to John’s question about real-life conversations regarding different points of view, Robbie pointed out that he has often found himself trying to open up conversations and brokering discussions and failing due to people being unwilling to engage in debate. For him, this resulted in being forced out of the Green Party along with many other members of the party. You can find out more about them on the website Greens In Exile. Robbie mentioned that there is now a badge for the exiles reading ‘Greens in Exile’. Robbie feels that wearing it helps open up discussions about what is happening in the Green Party in particular, but in society in general as well.


The discussion then turned to the final passage of the book. Robbie felt quite confused with the last line of the book in which Jensen said that “A radical feminist analysis, rooted in an ecological worldview, offers a path to a deeper analysis and potentially more effective responses.“. Robbie felt that the book ended rather abruptly at this point and he was left with wondering about the available choices would be if they weren’t either a “liberal embrace or a conservative rejection”. Robbie’s confusion stemmed from a realisation that meeting people in different arenas requires a ‘need’ to adapt your language and as such he was unsure which responses radical feminism would be able to provide in those contexts. Robbie’s confusion stemmed from a rather literal reading of the passage. Björn, who had taken the sentence in a more philosophical way, felt that Jensen was trying to say that issues are complex and our responses to them should be informed by deep thinking and critical analysis from a radical feminist perspective. Only by engaging in that way, can we ensure that the responses we come up with are better than the blanket responses of ‘affirmation’ on one side versus ‘rejection’ on the other.


To round the discussion off, Chris noted how Jensen had vehemently rejected the term ‘TERF’ and how important this was, in a sense of not describing ourselves or others using derogatory and incorrect terms. Neither radical feminists nor MACS exclude people who identify as trans. We are simply concerned about protecting vulnerable women, children, same-sex attracted people and bisexual people and want to stop anyone from doing anything nasty.


Chris’ point garnered some support, whilst others felt it was possible to reclaim derogatory terms like ‘TERF’. In the end we had to agree to disagree, whether such a reclaiming is indeed possible. We ended the discussion by reflecting on our takes on various ‘labels’ currently doing the rounds that reflect ‘gender critical’ views. These included ‘gender atheist’, ‘gender realist’ or ‘sex realist’ (a term that someone had come across on Reality’s Last Stand).

Comments are closed.

↑
Subscribe Newsletter
close slider

Subscribe to the MACS Newsletter




* indicates required

Would you like to hear from Male Allies Challenging Sexism CIC?

 

 

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

 

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking above to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices.